Learning French with Duolingo - Pros and Cons

I started learning French in 1999

I’ve been learning (or trying to learn) French since 1999 when I started working for a French multinational in Mumbai and Alliance Française’s French classes were offered for free. I finished Niveau Un (Level 1) in French when I moved on from that job and though my next job didn’t have a French connection, I persisted with my efforts to learn French, my long working hours and other personal commitments notwithstanding. My motivation? I had fallen in love with French. I signed up for Aliance Française’s Niveau Deux, listened to audio lessons and would go to the Theosophy Hall to watch French movies with subtitles. The Niveau Deux required me to attend classes in the morning from eight to ten, five days a week at Dhanraj Mahal in Colaba. Halfway through the three month course, I was forced to drop out after a M&A transaction I was working on required me to take a cab at eight thirty in the morning to reach a due diligence data room in far away Andheri. I continued learning French on my own using audio tapes and books.

A Diplôme Supérieur from the LSE

After I started an LLM at the London School of Economics (2002-2003), I went to the LSE’s Language Centre and asked for French language courses. They made me take an assessment test and enrolled me for Niveau Trois, which led to a Diplôme Supérieur after a year. By that time, I could speak passable French (with some planning and deliberation) though I didn’t understand much of what I received in response. After leaving the LSE, I started working in London and slowly my French became rusty. Every once in a while, I would brush up, only to lapse back to beginner’s level. Between 2005 and 20012, I made five trips to France, each for around 5 days and before each trip, I could spend some days working on my French, but those were mere splashes in the pool.

Then Duolingo happened

In March 2019, I started using Duolingo to learn French. It was highly addictive and I was hooked. Initially, I would spend just 15 minutes a day on Duolingo, but soon, I was spending up to an hour every day. I was never into movies or cricket, but used to be a news junkie. After I was hooked on Duolingo, I actually stopped watching TV altogether to make time for Duolingo.  

My hold over French grammar used to be shaky. I could speak confidently, but with lots of grammatical mistakes. With Duolingo, my grip over grammar improved substantially. When learning French in a formal classroom with fifteen other students, you doesn’t always get feedback on the grammar exercises you do in class or as homework. You get to speak up or read a passage once in a while and get corrected. With Duolingo, the feedback is instant.

Holiday in Paris

In May 2019, we went on a week’s holiday to Paris, my sixth trip to France. Being able to speak French in Paris is useful, especially with cab-drivers and in cafes. However, three months of Duolingo hadn’t improved by ability to converse in French. In fact, I caught myself hesitating a lot more than I used to. This was understandable, I reasoned to myself. I was sure that once my grammar improved, I would get back to speaking confidently as I used to, albeit without mistakes.

A break from Duolingo

On my return, my work load increased and I cut back the time I spent on Duolingo to fifteen minutes a day, until I ceased altogether, I think by around August or September 2019. I stopped entirely more because it was addictive and sticking to a fifteen-minute-per-day regime was annoying. It was either all or nothing and since I couldn’t spend enough time with Duolingo, I stopped using it altogether. I did miss a lot though.

Reunited with Duolingo

Then in November 2020, my daughter announced that she would take French at school, starting June 2021 and I happily went back to Duolingo so that I could help her with her lessons. I started with fifteen or twenty minutes and day and so I was spending all my free time on Duolingo. Once again, I stopped watching TV altogether.

Scaling “Levels” and Acquiring “Skills”

Duolingo’s French course has nine “levels”, with between 24 to 30 “skills” in each “level”. To cross from one "level" to another, one has to cross a "checkpoint", which involves a test. Each skill involves a situation, such as “shopping” or “at work” or “office” or “flirting” or “education” or “sports” and all exercises in the skill involves such a situation. A “skill” could also be a grammar topic, such as “passe compose (past tense)” or “Objects”. Each “skill” has five levels and each level involves five or six exercises. Within each “skill”, the “levels” are supposed to increase in difficultly and complexity as one progresses from one to five. I found that the increase in difficulty is marginal and some of the questions from the lower levels are repeated at the higher “levels”.

In my first stint with Duolingo (March – August 2019), I used to finish all five “levels” in each “skill” before moving on to the next “skill”. In my second stint, I changed tack and started to do just one “level” of each “skill”, before moving on to the next skill. Finishing one “level” (out of five “levels”) of a “skill” is sufficient to get permission to move to the next “skill”. 

It is also possible to complete a level without completing all the (five or six) exercises in the “level” by taking a test. If you make four mistakes in the test, you flunk, but you can repeat the test immediately. Soon, I found that most of the time, I could clear the test for a “level” after doing one exercise. 

It came to pass that I would do one exercise in “level” one for a particular “skill” and then take the test to complete “level one”. Sometimes, I would fail the test, but if I took the test again, some of the questions would be repeated and so, I would easily pass on my second attempt. 

Is it an addiction?

Duolingo functions by making the user addicted to the learning process in various ways, which is both a good thing and a bad thing. It is a good thing because you enjoy and look forward to using Duolingo. It is a bad thing because, as I came to realise very slowly, you don’t learn much if you play with an app to earn rewards and XPs and to maintain a streak.

Quest for XPs

When one learns a language on Duolingo, one earns experience points, which are called “XP” for short. A single lesson to acquire a “skill” or a general practice session gets you at least 10 XP and usually there are bonus XPs. When you complete all five levels in a “skill”, you get XP.  When crossing from one level to another, there’s a quiz to be taken and if you are successful, you get 50 XP. Then there are Duolingo Stories which are actually quite good and the XP ranges from 14 to 28.

When you start using Duolingo, you choose a daily goal for earning XPs. Casual is 10 XP, Regular is 20 XP, Serious is 30 XP and Intense is 50 XP.

Leaderboards

Every user is placed on a “leaderboard”. The top ten XP performers of a league are promoted to a higher tier for the next week. One starts with Bronze and progresses through Silver, Gold, Sapphire, Ruby, Emerald, Amethyst, Pearl and Obsidian until one gets to the Diamond league. I progressed steadily, occasionally falling back. I got the Diamond league a few times and once I topped the Obsidian.

Your fellow learners on your leaderboard may not be learning the language that you are learning. The only two common factors are that you are on Duolingo and you are hungry for XPs.

Once addicted, one goes way past the daily XP goal, in order to be go up the leaderboard.

If you don’t keep up, others get to know of it.

 

Rewards

There are a number of rewards on Duolingo, for reasons ranging from frivolous (adding a profile picture (Photogenic), practising on a weekend (Weekend Warrior), following three friends (Friendly), reading a tip (Strategist)) to more serious shit, such as earning 30,000 XP (Sage), learning 2,000 new words in a single course (Scholar), making it to the Diamond League (Champion), completing 100 lesson without a mistake (Sharpshooter), Finishing #1 in the Diamond League (Legendary), finishing #1 in my leaderboard (Winner), reaching a 125 day streak (Wildfire) and earning 2 crowns in every “skill” in a course (Conqueror).

I am Photogenic, a Weekend Warrior, Friendly, a Strategist, a Sage (though I’m pretty sure I don’t know 2000 French words), a Scholar, a Champion, a Sharpshooter and a Winner. The only three rewards I haven’t got are Wildfire, Conqueror and Legendary.

Maintaining a Streak

If you keep hitting your daily XP target for more than a day, you are on a streak. If you do it for two days, you are on a two day streak, if you do it for ten days, you are on a ten day streak, if you do it for eighty days, you are on a eighty day streak. Folks who use Duolingo often boast about their steak on social media such as LinkedIn and Facebook, I guess it shows that they are consistent and persistent. Duolingo not only encourages you to maintain a streak, it has various aids to help you maintain your streak. 

You can buy a weekend amulet to make sure that your streak is not lost if you fail to practice during the weekend.

If you make a mistake

If you make a mistake during a lesson, you immediately get to see the correct answer and the lesson doesn’t end until you do it right, which is easy since you have seen the answer. 

If a lesson has fifteen questions and you get questions five, eight and twelve wrong, then after the fifteenth question, questions five, eight and twelve will pop up again and you know what the correct answer is. So, there is no incentive is pondering over a question to get it right. Instead, the temptation is to answer it somehow, see the correct answer, move on and answer the same question towards the end.

Dual choice questions

When there is one blank and two choices, the correct answer is always the second one.

When there are two blanks and two choices, the second choice always goes into the first blank.

Jumbled sentences

A bulk of the exercises involve choosing words from amongst a pile to form a correct sentence. Even if one doesn’t know French, it is possible to form the correct sentence. 

However, I assume, the exposure to the words teaches you something. Unless you are in a tearing hurry and only want to get XPs.  

One of the mistakes I made most often when forming sentences from out of jumbled words was using “the” instead of “this”.

English meanings for French words

When doing an exercise, one can learn the meanings of French words by clicking on them. So, answering a question is pretty easy.

Constant encouragement

As one learns, one is constantly encouraged in various ways. If one spends thirty minutes on Duolingo, one’ll  be encouraged in at least five different ways. 

The next day, the same messages of encouragement pop up. I started to find the messages annoying or condescending.

You are encouraged to encourage those you follow and you receive encouragement from them in turn.

Oral practice

If you use the Duolingo app on your smart phone, a big chunk of the exercises are oral.

You need to listen to a sentence and repeat it. Even if you do not say a few of the words correctly, you pass. 

Maybe the app assumes, it’s a problem with the mike. On the rare occasion Duolingo rejects the oral response, you get to try again immediately. 

So, it is much easier to pass each lesson on the smart phone app than when doing the same lesson on the laptop. It is also possible to opt out of oral lessons when using the smart phone app.

Alternately, you need to listen to a French sentence and then pick words from out of a pile to form it.

Hard exercises

After the first few levels, each lesson has two tough questions at the fag end. Usually, these are tougher than the preceding questions.

Diverse, Funny, Whacky and Weird

One of the best things about Duolingo is the sheer diversity of the topics used to teach French.

Mauvais Anglais

Once in a blue moon, the English doesn’t make sense or read too well.

Playing and skimming, not diving

I realised that I was playing with French, skimming through exercises, not diving deep enough. When I think back to the French classes I had at the Alliance Francais de Bombay or at the LSE’s Language Centre, I realise that the lessons there gave me lots of time to think and made me look for answers. I am pretty sure that, though I learned a lot of new words on Duolingo, I don’t remember most of them and my entire French vocabulary dates back from my pre-Duolingo days.

Duolingo Stories

These are distinct from “Skills”, but are easy to do and generate a lot more XPs. More than on one occasion, when I was in the Obsidian league and wanted to get into the Diamond league, I found myself doing more “stories” than lessons and it worked. I moved into the Diamond league. Some of the stories are really good and most of the characters are good and real. If I were in search of entertainment, I would give these stories five stars.

One particular story of an office worker sneaking into her boss’s cabin to read a document on his computer (which had a list of promotions) was especially engrossing.

Diversity

Duolingo’s characters are diverse in various ways. 

Vikram and Priti, who are vegetarian, are an integral part of the French speaking cast.

As Free As the Air

Duolingo is free to use – one only needs to register. However, Duolingo Plus requires payment and one gets to use Duolingo without being interrupted by ads.

 

If you refer a friend who signs up to join Duolingo, then you get Duolingo Plus for a couple of weeks. 

During my first stint with Duolingo, I got Duolingo Plus for a couple of weeks twice by referring friends.

Exit from Duolingo

I haven’t used Duolingo since July 11, 2021. Though I didn’t use Duolingo since July 11, 2021, I used my streak freeze for a few days after that. I kept getting various reminders, through app notifications and by email, to keep my streak frozen.

On July 17, 2021, my streak stays frozen. If I use Duolingo on July 18, 2021 and accumulate 50 XP or more, I will have a 83 day streak, despite not having used Duolingo for six days. 

Will I return to Duolingo?

I think I will return to Duolingo sooner than later.

Duolingo is an incredible resource, the best free resource to learn a foreign language that is currently available online. However, to really learn French and to make optimum use of Duolingo, I need to train myself to not to focus on XPs or streaks or my position on the leaderboard and to couple my Duolingo lessons with watching TV5, reading French newspapers and practising French with other French wannabes.